Nurse’s gloomy prediction carries a kernel of truth for some

A nurse's comment, noting that an elderly woman will likely die earlier because of a broken hip may be true for some, but not for specific individuals, Dr. Keith Roach notes.



December 9, 2021 - 9:34 AM

DEAR DR. ROACH: I am a 73-year-old woman. I recently fell in my house doing housework and surprisingly broke my left hip. Before the fracture I was in excellent health and extremely active. I walked daily, went to the gym and did both weight resistance and aerobic workouts. I am on no other medications other than a thyroid pill that I take daily, because my thyroid was burned out many years ago due to being overactive. I am 5 feet, 3 inches tall, weigh 115 pounds and eat healthy to maintain it. Before surgery, the surgeon’s nurse told me, “You will die sooner now, probably 30% sooner because you broke your hip and you will never be the same.” The doctor decided to pin it rather than give me an artificial hip because he said my bones looked well enough to hold the pins. I resumed as much physical activity as I could in a short period of time. Am I really destined to have a shortened life now and never get back to where I was? — S.P.

ANSWER: First off, what the nurse said may be true, on average, for a large group of people, but is NOT necessarily true for an individual. Second, what a horrible thing to say! Many patients, usually women but some men, do very well after their hip surgery. The fact that you were so active and healthy before the fall is a very good sign for your recovery and long-term prognosis, as is the fact that you have been able to recover activity quickly after the surgery. Only time will tell how much function you will recover, but it could be nearly complete.

You have at least two possible risk factors for a hip fracture. The first is that you are quite thin, with a body mass index of just 20.4, which is well below the average. This puts you at higher risk for a hip fracture, especially if you are white or Asian. The second is that you have a history of an overactive thyroid. 

May 19, 2022
April 14, 2022
March 22, 2022
February 25, 2022